“Between Color and Voice” — A New Hope For Indonesian Trans Women


Reading time : 5 minutes

Photographs by Yoppy Pieter
Words by Sharonna Valezka

Published on August 11, 2021

Share this :

Yoppy Pieter documents how Covid-19 affects the marginalised community.

Yoppy Pieter
Liliana Saharon (left), Jamilah Tan (middle), and Olive (right) apply make-up on themselves before busking. During the pandemic, they decided to live together to save on rent. Their daily work as a stylist had to stop while the Large-Scale Social Restriction is being implemented.

Through his series of images, titled “Between Color and Voice”, the Indonesian photographer Yoppy Pieter documents how the Covid-19 pandemic has affected the trans women community. For this visual storyteller, the pandemic hasn’t just destroyed systems, but revealed the deep structural inequalities beneath.

In July 2021, Indonesia became the new epicentre of the Covid-19 pandemic, surpassing India and Brazil to become the country with the world’s highest counts of new infections. According to The Jakarta Post, on July 14th alone the country recorded a total number of 54,517 new daily cases and a death toll of 69,210. Facing its largest outbreaks yet, the Government began reimposing restrictions such as lockdowns and stay-at-home orders, as well as accelerating ongoing vaccination efforts to prevent future outbreaks.

While everyone else rushed to get vaccinated, the individuals of the Indonesian LGBTQI+ community, particularly trans women, were faced with difficulties in gaining access to Covid-19 vaccines and social assistance.

Working with the National Geographic Society to document the impact of Covid-19 around the world, Pieter travelled to the home of trans women communities in the hardest-hit areas of Jakarta, West Java, and Banten to document the struggles faced by the communities.

“We all agree that Covid-19 has an impact on everyone, but it is different for these communities who have experienced discrimination long before the pandemic started,” he says. Pieter further explained that in Indonesia, most trans women leave their homes in their teenage years, due to domestic conflicts over their identity. They left their family without proper education and official documents such as ID cards and family cards.

“It’s hard to imagine how much of an obstacle it is living without ID cards and proper education. They cannot work in the formal sector and end up being trapped in poverty. With the current ongoing pandemic, having no official documents can lead to them losing healthcare access and government assistance.” he adds.

Yoppy Pieter
The slum area in Depok, West Java. Many trans women live in this area as it provides affordable rooms for rent that cost IDR 300.000 – IDR 600.000. But during the pandemic, most of them have not been able to pay rent because they have lost their sources income.
Yoppy Pieter
Mira (not her real nickname) works as a commercial sex worker in Jakarta. Since the implementation of Large-Scale Social Restriction in Jakarta, she no longer works on the street, instead she has transfered online. “I have no options. I need to work to pay rent and living expenses,” she says. “Feelings of fear must be there, but when guests come over, I ask him to take a shower and clean up before we do business.”
Yoppy Pieter
Lilis (middle) is being accompanied by Aurel (left) from Pelita Tangsel to do a routine HIV/AIDS test in Serpong, South Tangerang.

For Pieter, his project is a representation of how society tends to overlook individuals with their own definitions of identity that are considered unconventional by the standard norms. One of his goals for the project is to be able to convey the message of equality as a part of human rights that every individual deserves. The idea of visual language that he used to communicate his message to the viewers is the archetype of the community’s inner fear and strength in a philosophical approach. 

In addition, this approach highlights his observations of isolation, survival and the importance of solidarity in the community. Living with a negative stigma and being victims of systematic discrimination has put the community in a state of poverty and depression, and so his images reflected how these individuals view their communities as a safe haven that represents family, home and hope for resilience in the face of adversity.

Pieter says that every time he creates his works, he wants to be part of a change. Fortunately for him and the community, seven months after his project was published, the Indonesian Government started efforts to reach out to the community. It is in the process of facilitating trans women with official documents such as ID cards and family cards which will allow them to receive public services.

“I’m not saying that my project has made the change, but I’m glad to be a part of the change, alongside other initiatives,” he says. His project has certainly brought a new light to Indonesian trans women communities and unveiled a glimpse of hope for them after enduring a life full of hardships.

Yoppy Pieter
An ID card belonging to Darni, in the name of Darno, has expired since 2012. The widower marital status bears her family’s story. “I was arranged to marry a woman, but it lasted only two months,” says Darni. This kind of story is experienced by many trans women in Indonesia as their sexual orientation is considered as a disease that can be cured by marriage.
Yoppy Pieter
Mama Dona lays on Mami Yuli’s knee. As the leader of the Indonesian Transwoman Forum, Mami Yuli dedicated herself to fight for trans women’s rights in society. In 2010, she established Rumah Singgah in Depok, West Java as a safe place for elderly trans women to live peacefully.

Share this :

Follow us :





A New Talent Takes Root

A New Talent Takes Root

Ranuth Yun looks back at his artistic journey to becoming an image-maker who is perplexing…
Own Your Waste

Own Your Waste

Raphael Pech creates a photo series underlining one of Earth’s biggest contaminants — plastic. And…